Bronx
Pelham Bay
39 closed sales · last 12 months
Updated monthly from closed-sale data.
Pelham Bay is a sub-neighborhood within Throgs Neck-Schuylerville. The median sale price is $665,000, with homes selling at $412.25 per square foot. About 15 homes sold annually, and properties typically spent 106 days on the market.
Over the last 12 months, Pelham Bay has outperformed Throgs Neck-Schuylerville it sits within.
Median Price
$665K
Half of sales closed above this price, half below.
Price / SF
$458/SF
Median closed price per square foot.
Closed Sales
39
Number of closed sales in the period.
Price Trend
Last 12 monthsClosed Sales
Who lives here
- 50,900
- Residents
- $65K
- Median household income
- $2K/mo
- Median rent
Source: U.S. Census (ACS), 2023 · Pelham Bay (1 ZIP code)
Pelham Bay on the map
Notable nearby
Restaurants
- Crab Island Cajun Seafood Express0.1 mi
- Sushi Q Japanese Restaurant0.1 mi
- Rosa Blanca Bar & Grill0.1 mi
Coffee
- Sundays Off Cafe0.1 mi
- Italia Cafè Lounge0.2 mi
- Lindy's Café Pelham Bay, Ny0.3 mi
Bookstores
- The Foldest Trick in the Book0.1 mi
- Collector Cave0.2 mi
- Pelham Bay Library0.2 mi
Nightlife & culture
- Crisrose Tavern Inc0.3 mi
- Shamrock Inn0.3 mi
- Bases Loaded Sports Bar0.3 mi
Shopping
- L & L Home Appliance Service0.1 mi
- Razor Sharp0.1 mi
- Ava's Rainflorist0.1 mi
Getting around
Nearest stop: CROSBY AV/ZULETTE AV · 2 min walk
Schools nearby
- PS 71 Rose E ScalaElementary · 5 min walk
- E Monroe New Renaissance BasketballHigh · 6 min walk
- PS 721 Stephen McSweeney SchoolHigh · 7 min walk
- Renaissance High School for Musical Theater and the ArtsHigh · 8 min walk
- Herbert H Lehman High SchoolHigh · 8 min walk
- Westchester Square AcademyHigh · 8 min walk
Key details
The cost of homes
The median sale price in Pelham Bay is $665,000, roughly $12,000 lower than the Throgs Neck-Schuylerville median of $677,000. Homes typically sell between $320,500 and $753,900.
Housing stock
The market moves at 105.7 days on average from listing to sale. Properties here trade at $412.25 per square foot. Annual sales volume runs at 15 transactions. Recent activity tracks in line with the broader Throgs Neck-Schuylerville area.
Nearby neighborhoods
All figures reflect sales only; rentals are excluded.
Thinking about a move in this neighborhood?
Get a personalized valuation or talk through the market with a local expert.