Manhattan
Turtle Bay
820 closed sales · last 12 months
Updated monthly from closed-sale data.
East Midtown-Turtle Bay is a neighborhood within All Midtown. The median sale price is $1,080,000, with properties averaging $1,319.72 per square foot. Annual sales volume reached 743 transactions.
Over the last 12 months, Turtle Bay has trailed All Midtown it sits within.
Median Price
$975K
Half of sales closed above this price, half below.
Price / SF
$1,305/SF
Median closed price per square foot.
Closed Sales
820
Number of closed sales in the period.
Price Trend
Last 12 monthsClosed Sales
Who lives here
- 49,325
- Residents
- $159K
- Median household income
- $3K/mo
- Median rent
Source: U.S. Census (ACS), 2023 · Turtle Bay (2 ZIP codes)
Livability
Tortus Score
Tortus Score rates walkability, transit, and nearby amenities across 1,070 locations in Turtle Bay. Higher is better.
Turtle Bay on the map
Notable nearby
Restaurants
- Atwood, Kitchen & Bar79 ft
- Sweet Annie's Bar & Eatery84 ft
- Mimi's Piano Bar95 ft
Coffee
- SARISA Cafe280 ft
- Organic Harvest Cafe370 ft
- Caffe Panino370 ft
Bookstores
- Quest Bookshop of the New York Theosophical Society253 ft
- McKinsey & Company, Incorporated, Tokyo0.1 mi
- Adam Weinberger Rare Books0.1 mi
Nightlife & culture
- Turtle Bay NYC74 ft
- Murphy's Irish Pub84 ft
- Bareburger127 ft
Shopping
- Just Food For Dogs84 ft
- Nuts Factory190 ft
- Buttercup Bake Shop248 ft
Getting around
Nearest stop: 2 AV/E 54 ST · 1 min walk
Schools nearby
- Art and Design High SchoolHigh · 4 min walk
- PS 59 Beekman Hill InternationalElementary · 4 min walk
- East Side Elementary School-Ps 267Elementary · 11 min walk
- PS 183 Robert L Stevensonother · 14 min walk
- Ella Baker SchoolElementary · 15 min walk
- Talent Unlimited High SchoolHigh · 15 min walk
Key details
The cost of homes
The median sale price in East Midtown-Turtle Bay is $1,080,000, roughly $81,000 higher than the All Midtown median of $999,000. Homes typically sell between $668,750 and $1,800,000.
Housing stock
Properties in East Midtown-Turtle Bay are priced at $1,319.72 per square foot, with a typical listing spending 203 days on market. The neighborhood recorded 743 sales annually, underperforming compared to All Midtown over the last 12 months.
Nearby neighborhoods
All figures reflect sales only; rentals are excluded.
Thinking about a move in this neighborhood?
Get a personalized valuation or talk through the market with a local expert.